the honest vpn comparison

The VPN market runs on affiliate money.
We show you the receipts.

Every VPN compared - commercial, free, decentralized, self-hosted - with dated evidence: who owns whom, whose "no-logs" survived a court case, what subscriptions really cost after the intro term, and which free paths get you the same result for nothing.

Our promise: rankings are provisions-blind (a test in our codebase enforces that scores cannot read affiliate data), every source carries an evidence class [A]-[D], and where you do not need a commercial VPN we say so.

evidence-classed facts [A]-[D] ownership graph + incident timeline we disclose every dollar

Start with the honest question

Do you need a commercial VPN at all? We compare every kind on its own terms - a self-hosted WireGuard tunnel is never scored against a free app, and a free app is judged harder than a paid service because the incentives are worse.

Hard truths before you pay

Three things the affiliate-funded review industry will not tell you. Every provider page on this site carries the same honesty boxes.

  • A VPN does not make you anonymous. You move trust from your ISP to the VPN company - whose "no logs" promise is only as good as its evidence.
  • The $2.99 price is bait. Intro rates run 2-3 years, then renew at 3-4x. Only a few providers (Mullvad, IVPN) price flat and honestly.
  • Several top reviewers are owned by VPN companies. Kape owns ExpressVPN, CyberGhost, PIA - and vpnMentor + WizCase. Ziff Davis owns PCMag and IPVanish. Check who reviewed your "independent" source.

What changed

Price, status and privacy-evidence changes we logged. Full log →

  • privacy VPN Gate (public volunteer relay experiment) · logging evidence: ? → policy-only
  • price VPN Gate (public volunteer relay experiment) · ? → 0
  • facts VPN Gate (public volunteer relay experiment) · facts
  • privacy Calyx VPN · logging evidence: ? → policy-only
  • price Calyx VPN · ? → 0
  • price Calyx VPN · ? → 0

Top pick in each kind

Provisional fact-driven scores - performance is unscored until our own tests run. One pick per kind: a free app is never ranked against a commercial VPN, and a self-hosted tunnel is never ranked against a free app.

hide.me

A rare genuinely usable free plan (no card, P2P allowed on the 10 GB free tier) plus audited no-logs claims twice over - DefenseCode 2015 and Securitum 2024…

7
audited crypto accepted
intro €2.69/mo (about $3.04/mo)
Malaysia commercial vpn 10 d ago

Riseup VPN

The most trustworthy free VPN on structural grounds: an anarchist Seattle collective that has run since 1999, funds itself by donations, asks no account…

4.5
canary open source community-owned crypto accepted
free
United States free vpn 35 d ago

Sentinel dVPN (Cosmos bandwidth marketplace, token P2P)

Sentinel is real decentralized-VPN infrastructure - an open-source Cosmos chain with on-chain sessions, Wallet-only signup and per-gigabyte pricing that…

4.8
open source crypto accepted
intro $1 /mo
none verifiable (no legal entity confirmed 2026; on-chain governance via P2P stakers, docs maintained by validator Trinity - whitepaper-era SNT Foundation / Exidio unconfirmable) decentralized vpn (dvpn) 27 h ago

IPRoyal

A serious budget proxy provider - and this dossier says plainly what that means: IPRoyal is not a consumer privacy VPN. It sells access to a 64M+ IP pool of…

3.5
crypto accepted
intro $7 /GB
United Arab Emirates - ToS v10 (effective 2026-10-15) and Privacy Policy v7 name 'IPRoyal Services FZE LLC ... incorporated in the United Arab Emirates, license No 4387, ... Ajman'; privacy policy is written under UAE PDPL (Federal Decree-Law No. 45 of 2021), not GDPR. Company started in 2020 in Lithuania (Lithuanian founders; the bandwidth app is run by 'IPRoyal Pawns UAB' per a 2026 GDPR complaint thread); HQ and contracting entity have moved to the UAE proxy service 26 h ago

CactusVPN Smart DNS

CactusVPN is the bundle case in the Smart DNS vertical: a 2011 Moldovan three-friends shop that once sold Smart DNS as its own product line and has now folded…

6.3
audited
intro $3.96 /mo
Moldova - the about page says 'CactusVPN started as a small company in Moldova' (late 2011, three friends with ecommerce backgrounds); the Securitum audit names the contracting entity only as 'Cactus VPN LLC' with no registration country; the live site carries no postal imprint anywhere; one third-party review reports a later headquarters move to Canada, which conflicts with the Moldova story smart dns service 3 h ago

Amnezia VPN (self-hosted with obfuscation)

The most credible self-hosting on-ramp in the VPN space, built by and for people inside the censorship: the app is free and open source, you connect it to your…

6.2
audited open source
intro $5 /mo
Cyprus (EUPHORIATECH LIMITED, Nicosia, reg HE 484287 per site footer, verified 2026-11-02; IP rights in Portugal with Amnezia LDA, ops in Estonia) - for self-hosted users the operative jurisdiction is wherever their own VPS is hosted self-hosted vpn 27 h ago

All 67 providers →

VPN FAQ - the honest version

Do I actually need a VPN?

Often, no. If your traffic is HTTPS (the padlock), your ISP sees domains - not content - and a VPN does not make you anonymous, stop ads or prevent hacking. A VPN is the right tool when you want to hide your browsing from your ISP or the network you are on, avoid IP-based geo-blocking, or use public Wi-Fi safely. If you only need ad/tracker blocking, DNS-level tools do that cheaper. Work through the "Do I need a VPN?" check for a straight answer. Facts 2026-11-03.

Are free VPNs safe?

Most are not - but not all. The free app giants (SuperVPN, VPN Proxy Master, Turbo VPN and friends) monetize your data or your attention, and several have leaked millions of records. The honest free options are RiseupVPN (donation-funded, no accounts) plus the free tiers of Proton VPN and Windscribe - funded by their paid plans, not by selling you. The difference is the business model, not the price tag. See the free VPN hub for the full picture.

What does "no-logs" actually mean?

Nothing, by itself. It is a marketing claim unless it has been tested: either by a court case (police asked, nothing to hand over - Mullvad 2023, PIA twice) or by an independent audit of the specific claim. We grade every provider: court-proven, audited, promise-only, or contradicted (logs existed despite the claim - IPVanish 2016, PureVPN 2017, HideMyAss 2011).

Why do all "top 10 VPN" lists recommend the same five brands?

Because the affiliate market pays $50-150+ per signup and up to 100% of the first payment. The same five brands bid the most, so the same five brands top the lists - and several review sites are literally owned by VPN companies (Kape owns ExpressVPN, CyberGhost, PIA... and vpnMentor/WizCase). We publish every commission we can find and keep rankings affiliate-blind by design. See how we make money.

Which VPN works in China / Russia / Iran?

The protocol matters more than the brand. In China (2025-2026 state of the block): VLESS/Reality, AmneziaWG and Shadowsocks-2022 keep working; plain WireGuard and OpenVPN are detected and cut. In Russia, TSPU DPI kills unobfuscated protocols. Check the country pages for what works where - and assume any single tool can stop working within days during crackdowns.

Is a decentralized VPN (dVPN) better for privacy?

Usually not. A dVPN replaces one operator with many strangers - some of whom you must still trust - and payment often requires a token with its own privacy footprint. dVPNs are interesting for censorship resistance and payment privacy, but they are not a shortcut past the trust problem. We compare them honestly, including the dead ones.